‹Programming› 2018
Mon 9 - Thu 12 April 2018 Nice, France
Tue 10 Apr 2018 14:30 - 15:00 at Baie des Anges A - Session 3

There are style guides and best practices for many programming languages. Their goal is to promote uniformity and readability of code, consequentially reducing the chance of errors.

While programmers who are frequently using the same programming language tend to internalize most of its best practices eventually, little is known about what happens when they casually switch languages and write code in a less familiar language. Insights into the factors that lead to coding convention violations could help to improve tutorials for programmers switching languages, make teachers aware of mistakes they might expect depending on what language students have been using before, or influence the order in which programming languages are taught.

To approach this question, we make use of a large-scale data set representing a major part of the open source development activity happening on GitHub. In this data set, we search for Java and C++ programmers that occasionally program Python and study their Python code quality using a lint tool.

Comparing their defect rates to those from Python programmers reveals significant effects in both directions: We observe that some of Python’s best practices have more widespread adoption among Java and C++ programmers than Python experts. At the same time, python-specific coding conventions, especially indentation, scoping, and the use of semicolons, are violated more frequently.

We conclude that programming off-language is not generally associated with better or worse code quality, but individual coding conventions are violated more or less frequently depending on whether they are more universal or language-specific. We intend to motivate a discussion and more research on what causes these effects, how we can mitigate or use them for good, and which related effects can be studied using the presented data set.

Tue 10 Apr

14:30 - 16:00: PX/18 - Session 3 at Baie des Anges A
px-2018-papers14:30 - 15:00
Siegfried Horschig, Toni MattisHasso Plattner Institute, Robert HirschfeldHPI, University of Potsdam
px-2018-papers15:00 - 15:30
Friedrich SteimannFernuniversität
px-2018-papers15:30 - 16:00
Stefan MarrUniversity of Kent, Benoit DalozeJKU Linz, Austria
Pre-print Media Attached